Home › For Medical Professionals
The contribution of specialist family physicians to private sector health care in South Africa, and what needs to change.
Primary health care is the best way to care for most people. In South Africa’s private sector it is provided by general practitioners and by specialist family physicians (SFPs).
SFPs are trained and registered specialists, yet in private practice they are often paid as GPs, have limited rights to order the investigations their patients need, and are sometimes denied hospital admitting privileges.
This statement explains what SFPs do, the value they add, and the changes funders, hospitals and regulators need to make. It is drawn from the experience of SFPP members and a review of local and international literature, and is endorsed by the South African Academy of Family Physicians and the South African Society of Specialist Family Physicians.
Two groups of doctors work at the primary care level in the private sector.
| General practitioner (GP) | Specialist family physician (SFP) | |
|---|---|---|
| Qualification | MBChB (basic medical degree) | MBChB plus a Master’s in Family Medicine (MMed) and Fellowship (FCFP) of the Colleges of Medicine of SA |
| Training after medical school | Internship and community service; many add further diplomas | Internship and community service, then four years of specialist training in family medicine |
| HPCSA registration | General practitioner | Specialist in Family Medicine |
| Role | First-contact and ongoing primary care for individuals and families | Complex, multiple and long-term conditions across all ages; works alongside GPs and other specialists |
SFPs are often confused with GPs. In the public sector they are employed and paid as consultants; in the private sector most schemes still pay them as GPs.
- First contactSkilled at assessing the ‘undifferentiated’ patient: building rapport, careful history-taking, clinical and procedural skill, motivational interviewing and psychological assessment.
- Comprehensive, person-centred careManage conditions across paediatrics, obstetrics and gynaecology, internal medicine, emergency medicine, surgery, palliative care, psychiatry and more, often without hospital-based referral.
- Coordination of careBring the multi-disciplinary team together, review medicines across prescribers to prevent harmful interactions, and advocate for the patient in hospital.
- Continuity of careA long-term relationship that prevents repeat tests and duplicated treatment, and lowers after-hours care, acute admissions and premature death.
- Enhanced chronic careOne practitioner can care for several family members and conditions at one visit, synchronising scripts, blood tests and check-ups.
Examples from the full position statement.
Miss N, 24: one doctor, the whole picture
After months of headaches, fatigue and poor sleep, and several visits that ended in painkillers and sedatives, an extended consultation with an SFP uncovered post-traumatic stress, depression, medicine dependency and interrupted HIV treatment.
The SFP coordinated a psychologist and social worker, started appropriate treatment and restarted her HIV care. Six months later her viral load was suppressed, her headaches had settled and her mood had improved, without imaging, admission or unnecessary prescriptions.
Mrs A, 55: catching a heart attack early
Mrs A’s SFP managed her hypertension, cholesterol and diabetes with her cardiologist and endocrinologist. When she called with chest pain she was seen the same day, and an in-rooms ECG showed a heart attack.
The SFP arranged immediate transfer for a stent, kept her chronic medicines going in hospital, updated her other specialists and followed her up with cardiac rehabilitation after discharge.
SFP-led management of chronic disease benefits patients, funders and the state. One study of family-physician-led pain care found a 26% reduction in health care costs over six months.
SFPs hold a specialist practice number from the Board of Healthcare Funders and are registered as specialists by the HPCSA, yet in private practice they face these problems.
1. Inadequate medical scheme recognition
The problem: Not all schemes recognise the SFP qualification, so SFPs are limited to a GP scope.
The solution: Clear recognition as a specialist group, with tariffs that reflect the complexity of managing multiple conditions.
2. Poor communication with subject specialists
The problem: SFPs are often left out of care plans after referral, even at discharge.
The solution: Recognise the SFP as the central coordinator of care, and treat a referral as complete only once the patient is referred back.
3. Poorly defined roles
The problem: Funders and the proposed NHI do not distinguish SFPs from GPs.
The solution: Include SFPs in specialist staffing and multi-disciplinary teams, from hospital to step-down, rehab, hospital-at-home and palliative care.
4. Inadequate remuneration
The problem: No specialist tariff structure exists for SFPs, as it does for other disciplines.
The solution: A tiered billing system for longer, more complex consultations, and payment for in-rooms procedures such as minor surgery, ultrasound, stress ECGs and IV infusions.
5. Restricted specialist privileges
The problem: SFPs often cannot order advanced tests and imaging, and some hospital groups deny admitting rights.
The solution: Give SFPs authority to order appropriate investigations and medicines, and to admit patients.
SFPs provide comprehensive, coordinated care and improve clinical governance and continuity of care. They reduce poly-pharmacy, unnecessary investigations and hospital admissions, which lowers health care costs and improves outcomes.
After more than 17 years as a recognised specialty, SFPs in private practice need the same recognition and remuneration as their peers in other specialties.
